Taipei’s Vicious Cycle: Snatching Space from Pedestrians is Not the Answer

Below is the original version of my editorial/whinge from today’s Taipei Times:

“Oi, Miggins! Don’t even think about straying from that path!”
Photo courtesy of the Guardian.


Years ago I was tinkled by a cyclist on the sidewalk outside the student dorms at Shida. In response, I engaged in my version of what soccer goalies call “making yourself big” – deliberately positioning my body to obstruct passage. Why? Well, for one thing I’m just awkward. But also because Taipei is such a horrible city for committed pedestrians that I cannot abide people encroaching on what limited space we have.

This incident occurred shortly after I had done my 50cc scooter test. In Taiwan that’s 100 percent written. In addition to learning that poorly dressed motorists sully national pride and that it’s poor form to splash pedestrians on rainy days, I confirmed that bicycles were not allowed on sidewalks.

By an extraordinary and extraordinarily satisfying coincidence, I had a printout from the Department of Transportation (DOT) Web site in my backpack to corroborate this when the tinkler argued to the contrary. Flabbergasted, as I brandished the document, he latched on to the Asahi tallboy in my other hand. “You’re not allowed to drink beer in the street in America,” he retorted with magnificent irrelevance.

The effort to turn Taipei into a cycle city has borne fruit. Last week, the Guardian ran a piece on the initiatives that have shot bike usage figures for the city way past those of New York and London. The author of the article, who was in town for the Velo-City 2016 event, heaped deserved praise on the YouBike system and the riverside cycling paths.

He also referenced a threefold increase in cycle lanes within three years, though the caveat that this extra space would be on the sidewalk and, thus, taken from pedestrians was telling. Another interesting figure was the 240 miles of sidewalk that is now apparently open in its entirety to cyclists.

Rereading the piece at a café, I smelled something dodgy, and it wasn’t the flaccid scrambled egg. The author’s description of a short jaunt around Taipei gave the impression that sidewalk cycling is legitimate pretty much anywhere. This raised questions. Firstly, considering most cyclists – and certainly most YouBikers – stick to the sidewalk as it is, giving official sanction to the practice seems redundant. Also, why bother creating more separate lanes on the sidewalk if swathes of it are already available to cyclists?

I called Taipei City Government to find out. “I don’t know,” a young lady told me after sustained prevarication. “You can ask the police.”

By the time I had impressed on her how unimpressed I was with this answer, demanded something better, then been subjected to several loops of mandopop Muzak, my 10 minutes was up – this being the maximum time allotted for each inquiry. To the local cop shop, then, it was, for some communal recrimination.

“They told you to come here?” the desk officer asked. “They’re useless.” I didn’t argue. “It’s pretty unprofessional, and ridiculous, isn’t it?” A junior officer who had sidled up chortled. “Welcome to Taiwan!” he piped, in English.

As far as the police were concerned, riding on the pavements is illegal anywhere in Taipei, though they weren’t prepared to be quoted on that. “Who knows,” said the junior officer. “The city government will probably blame us for their mistakes.”

No! And blurring your face out won’t help you when I get my hands on you!

The following day I happened to be close to City Hall and decided to pin someone down on this. After some false turns, I found the DOT office on sixth floor of the northwest wing. After some preliminaries, I was directed to subdivison chief, a nice young chap named Ryan Lin (林俊源).

“Nick?” he asked as we sat down at at desk in a corner of the cramped office. “Erm, no, James.” Suddenly I twigged: Nick Mead, the author of the Guardian article. It turned out Lin had met him during the Velo-City event. “Right, Nick.”

It took a minute to confirm that, aside from a limited number of signposted dual-purpose pedestrian areas and clearly demarcated sidewalk bike lanes, cycling is not permitted anywhere on sidewalks in Taipei. Relating my hitherto fruitless investigations, I observed that considerable confusion over the regulations remained. He nodded, a wry smile flickering across his lips. “Thanks for clarifying,” he said, well aware of the irony.

Someone obviously gave Mead the 240-mile figure, though I’ve yet to have anyone confirm this. As far as the Taipei City authorities are concerned, there has been no change in the regulations governing riding on the sidewalk. On the face of it, this is welcome news. I certainly found the claim disconcerting, which is one of the reasons I decided to find out.

However, the fact is, the laws continue to be flouted, and in all my time in Taipei, I have yet to see a police officer taking a transgressor to task. When I asked the police if they ever took action, they shrugged. Sidewalk cycling is unofficially and tacitly accepted.

Little wonder Mead might have come off with the impression that it was fair game city-wide, a notion of which none of his local guides seems to have attempted to disabuse him. After all, confuse our foreign guest with legal technicalities, especially when they might tarnish the image of Taipei as a city where everything proceeds with the utmost smoothness and harmony?

Although he admits that there is “potential for conflict,” Mead writes that he did not encounter any during his short visit.“Riding on the pavement feels 100 percent safe,” he writes, though he does addend the telling proviso “for the cyclists at least.”

Within this seemingly innocuous disclaimer lurks the kernel of the issue. I can well believe that Mead didn’t see any antagonism. Taiwanese are, in general, incredibly easygoing and nonconfrontational. A lack of remonstration by pedestrians should not, however, be taken as indicating an open-armed embrace of sidewalk cycling.

In fact, a 2015 DOT survey suggests at best, a grudging acquiescence: Well over a third of non-cyclists cite sidewalk riding as the most annoying “misbehavior” by cyclists. When failure to stick to designated paths is factored in, the figure rises to over 58 percent. Of course, the survey hinges on a presupposition that respondents are indeed irked by some aspect of cyclists’ behavior. Still, it’s obvious that more than a few people have their reservations.

I am one of them. Contrary to Mead’s depiction, there are parts of town where people whiz along the pavement with absolutely no concern for others. Stepping out from the arcade areas in Taipei, where the pillars of the overhang render one blind, can be a risky undertaking.

As was pointed out in these pages by Lolita Hu in 2013, “might makes right” has long been the guiding mantra for motorists in Taipei. That this extends all the way down to the bullying of pedestrians by cyclists is ever more apparent.

Widening sidewalks to add bicycle lanes to them is one thing, but permitting – legally or otherwise – Taipei’s sidewalks to become a free-for-all is simply dodging the problem. The dangers of Taipei’s roads are often raised in mitigation by sidewalk cyclists, many of whom have no such quandary about flying around the city’s clogged thoroughfares on scooters. Yet, is there any real difference between these two unprotected vehicles in the event of a broadsiding?

As I cyclist, I respect Taipei’s effort to get people onto bicycles. As a pedestrian, however, I am dismayed that appropriating pedestrian space is considered a viable variable in the equation. Trumpeting an increase in cycling space that is predicated on fleecing pedestrians is analogous to abducting babies from abroad then heralding a boost to domestic birthrates.

Rather than trying to fudge the figures, Taipei should be working harder to get cars off the street, cracking down on the idiotic driving that plagues the city, and encouraging assertive, confident cycling on the roads.










About the Author